Circlworld
Back to Charter Hall

Transparency · DSC outcomes

Dispute Settlement Centre — aggregate outcomes.

The DSC’s annual outcomes — concerns filed, mediations held, adjudications, appeals, average resolution times, lessons themes. Substantive content of mediation is confidential and remains so; this report is aggregate counts + outcome categories + lessons (the latter only where parties consented to publication).

Mediation privilege.

What is said in mediation is not used in adjudication, not surfaced in this report, and not used by CirclAI. The DSC’s mediation room is structurally confidential. This report shows that the room operates — not what was said inside it.

Top-line counts

Concerns filed

0

Mediations held

0

Adjudications

0

Appeals

0

Concerns by category

No concerns reported yet. When the first reporting cycle closes, concerns route into categories — Treasurer conduct, missed contribution, cycle order disagreement, Member departure, CPR application, Bylaws interpretation — with counts and shares.

Mediation outcomes

Mediation aims at resolution without escalation. The settlement rate publishes here once the first reporting cycle closes.

No mediation outcomes reported yet. When the first cycle closes, the four outcomes (settled at mediation / settled before close / withdrawn / escalated to adjudication) publish here with counts and shares of the total.

Adjudication outcomes

Where mediation does not settle, the matter routes to adjudication. The DSC’s decisions are recorded with reasoning; the aggregate outcome distribution publishes here once the first cycle closes.

No adjudication outcomes reported yet. When the first cycle closes, the four outcomes (upheld / partial uphold / dismissed / withdrawn) publish here with counts and shares.

Appeal outcomes

The DSC takes appeals seriously; appellate panels are constituted with fresh members. The appeal rate and outcome distribution publish here once the first cycle closes.

No appeals reported yet. When the first cycle closes, the three appellate outcomes (upheld at appeal / overturned at appeal / remanded to original room) publish here.

Average resolution times by room

No resolution-time metrics yet. When the first cycle closes, average days from filed-to-resolved publish here per room (Concerns Desk, Mediation, Adjudication, Appeals, Lessons).

Lessons themes

Where parties have consented to lesson publication per Charter §9.4, the DSC’s Lessons room aggregates patterns. The themes are general; no Member or Circle is identifiable. Treasurers and Members can use these patterns to anticipate + prevent similar concerns in their own Circles.

No published lesson themes yet — the Lessons room requires party consent (§9.4), and no consented lessons have been published. When the first lesson is published, general patterns surface here without identifying Members or Circles.

Dispute Settlement Centre Charter

The constitutional source — five rooms, mediation privilege, appeal route.

Treasurer governance transparency

Selection Committee outcomes are recorded there. Some Selection Committee decisions route to DSC appeal.